Showing posts with label left. Show all posts
Showing posts with label left. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Action and Reflection

Though this is ultimately a blog about Christian radical politics, we have been spending a lot of time so far on conceptual issues, and will continue to do so. This brief post will explain why we think this is a necessary task, and how we perceive this task.

It is common in left-leaning circles, theological or non, to insist that action is primary, with reflection coming afterward and leading back to action. In this view, presumably, right action is something we know about a priori, and reflection is to be understood and judged based on this already existing knowledge. Jesus' statement that "you will know them by their fruit" (cf. Matt. 7:16) is taken as confirmation of this view.

Along these lines, one never ceases to hear complaints about Karl Barth's theology that charge this "Red Pastor of Safenwil" with being too conceptual and not practical enough in his ethics (for a recent example, see here).

Finally, it is common today to find theologians espousing what has been called "strategic essentialism" on issues of sex and race. This method, while accepting the philosophical criticism of all "essentialisms," nevertheless makes use of essentialist thinking to advance (what is thought to be) liberating practice.

However, I think it not only possible but preferable to problematize, if not completely reverse this ordering. Reflection (theory, etc.), it seems clear to me,  accompanies, if it does not always preexist, all action worthy of the name. Of course, in our individual and corporate lives we tend to do a lot of things without thinking about them critically, from bodily functions such as breathing, to the use of language and symbols, to a whole host of more or less significant activities like engaging in commerce and the arts. But is this the kind of "action" that accords with liberation? I think not. Rather, that kind of action is done under a conscious interpretation, some sort of reflective construal of events and their significance.

Admittedly, and as a matter of simple fact, we are always already acting in our social lives under an interpretation, whether we are aware of it or not. But that would make the presciptive call to begin with action unnecessary. What is needed is always careful and perspicacious reflection. Only then can true action take place.

This is by no means to demean or belittle action, nor is it to minimize its importance or make it unnecessary. Rather, it understands action in such a way that reflection cannot be minimized or made unnecessary.

In the case of Barth, he was active in leftist politics before he was a professional theologian. The case of the philosopher Badiou is very similar: he, too, has been involved in political action about as long as he has been a philosopher. In both cases, these thinkers recognized more and more in their work that reflection and theory are absolutely necessary tasks to be undertaken in their own right. Otherwise, we lack the tools to see how it is that action so often goes astray, and we begin to lose any self-critical consciousness of our own goals and methods.

The Christian faith, interestingly enough, is in my view an idea about an action, specifically the action of God in Christ reconciling the world to himself. But even this action was done under an interpretation; it was a willfully chosen act. Here I think one can split the difference, as it were, between Hegelian and more traditional theology (for a discussion, see here). Hegelian theology sees the second person of the Trinity as the man Jesus, simply. Traditional theology sees the divine Son not only in the man Jesus (the logos incarnantus) but also always standing behind and to be understood in abstraction from the life of this man (the logos asarkos, defined as that which is neither incarnatus nor incarnandus). The middle way, and preferable to both of these alternatives, is to see the divine Son as always incarnandus. That means the divine Son as God's Word to the world is completely given in God's act of reconciliation in the man Jesus, but never to be reduced to this man. The Word is only in the humanity, relating to it in a way that is analogous (and more than analogous) to the relation between text and interpretation.

If, on the other hand, we think action is to be taken as absolutely primary, the inevitable result, I think, is that we assume a certain interpretation of events that will control both the action and the subsequent reflection, and never in such a way that it can be self-critical. I see this again and again in political and religious discussions. It is always assumed that what "we" (Americans, Presbyterians, etc.) did in the (recent or distant) past was obviously the right thing to do, so that further action must always be along the same lines and done under the same interpretation. Unfortunately, what appears again and again in these discussions is a battle over who gets to interpret the interpretation; that is, all seem eager to foist onto the past their preferred interpretation for the present and future. So whether we like it or not, we are always brought back to reflection.

Therefore we will continue on this blog to deal with the conceptual framework in its own right, working from that to the actions, political and otherwise, that are called for by that framework.

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Wag the Dogma: Opinions, Truth, and Ecclesiolatry

As a self-styled "radical Christian," I find myself fighting what seems to me to be a theological/intellectual disease very deep and prevalent in our contemporary situation, including in the churches. This disease has its heart and origin in the denial, on the one hand, of a subject matter capable of defending itself against the constructive manipulations of ideologies, and on the other, of a subject capable of standing on its own intellectual feet against communitarian embeddedness.

This disease has two dominant forms. The first form insists that because there is no such subject matter and subject, the only solution is to defer absolutely to the opinion of an authoritarian source or some collection of authoritarian sources. The second form of this same disease insists that the solution is to defer to every opinion equally. And anyone who, like myself, refuses one of these solutions is always presumed to be accepting the other one.

It is rather like trying to defend oneself against two tribes of zombies. One tribe angrily yells at you "GIVE ME YOUR BRAINS NOW!" The other asks, pleads, and manipulates, saying, in effect, "If you are a nice person and want to avoid having your brains devoured by the first tribe, just let each of us take a little nibble. If you do not, we will be very hurt and disappointed with you."

In the churches today, one constantly encounters pleas to be "humble" by giving up one's own view and going along with everyone else. No charge is considered more damning than that of "individualism." Individualism is criticized as being "modern," "western," etc. In direct opposition to this, radical Christianity, as I conceive it, is irreducibly individualistic.

First, let's define the term. "Individualism" as I define it does not mean selfishness, a refusal to be in community with others, or the like. Rather, it is a way of being in community, of being in relation to others, and of responsibly acting with and toward one's neighbors. It means being a self, a definite locus of thought and activity. Additionally, it is more of a prescriptive than a descriptive idea. I do not doubt that, as a matter of descriptive fact, everyone finds him- or herself in a community or a nexus of overlapping communities, which bring with them all kinds of assumptions, biases, and so on, not all of which we can resist perfectly, or even be clearly aware of. But a person ought to work to own up to his or her own thoughts and take responsibility for them. In fact, everyone is responsible, in the sense of morally or ethically culpable, for what he or she thinks, regardless of where the idea comes from. At least to an extent, and a significant one at that, taking responsibility for one's own thoughts is possible. That is what I mean by "individualism."

It is my view that, contrary to popular opinion, this kind of individualism is prevalent in the Bible, especially in the New Testament. It is the corrolary of the move, apparent especially in the Apostle Paul's letters, against settled communitarian distinctions that would divide the Church or order it hierarchically. This is how I read the famous "neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free" from Galatians.

This kind of individualism means that each person is responsible for his or her own faith. By no means do I intend here to downplay the role of the Holy Spirit; in fact, this role dovetails nicely with individualism. Because we believe by an act of God in our hearts, we are never bound directly to, nor dependent upon, anyone else for our faith.

Finally, this kind of individualism does not contradict, but actually supports socialist, even communist collectivism. It is because we, as individuals, have our own thoughts, that when our common thoughts agree, we can act in egalitarian unity.

Ecclesiologically, this means that our churches ought to embody this kind of individualist collectivism. We come together, as the Gospel of Matthew puts it, in Jesus' name. In my view, that does not mean we use the name of Jesus as a mere word, void of definitive reference, waiting to be filled in by our opinions. Rather, "in Jesus' name" means according to the truth of God's act and being in the irreducible particularity of the human life, death, and resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth. In other words, it is our common idea, which each person holds individually, that brings the Church together.

The usual assumption today is quite different. It is often assumed that whenever people are together in an ecclesiological institution, they are duty-bound to hold onto some kind of unity no matter what happens, and no matter how superficial this unity turns out to be. Strangely, perhaps, this idea seems more prevalent in the so-called "left wing" of denominations more than the right wing. But in the final analysis, this move is inherently right wing.

Therefore our determination is to be individuals, not so that we can avoid collective activity, but so that our collective activity, when it happens, will not be superficial but deep and authentic. Doctrine, or ideas, should lead here, not unity for its own sake. Otherwise, the tail is wagging the dogma.